When 'No' Isn't Enough: Understanding the Drive to Move and the Importance of Redirection
Share
An infant, as young as nine or ten months repeatedly attempts to climb onto a chair and then up onto a table. A childcare practitioner at the Setting notices the potential danger and responds with a clear, calm instruction: "No, we don't climb on the table."
The child pauses, looks towards the adult and, moments later, tries again.
For the supervising adult, this can be a frustrating experience. The instruction has been given, the child appears to have heard it, and yet the behaviour continues. It is tempting to interpret this as testing boundaries, deliberately ignoring instructions or challenging adult authority.
But what if we were to look at this situation differently?
What if, rather than seeing the child's repeated attempts as an act of defiance, we understood them as an expression of a powerful developmental drive – one that the child is not yet able to regulate independently
In the example of the chair and table, the child may be exploring balance, strength, coordination, spatial awareness, height and the possibilities of their own body. We all know many infants love to be elevated and so they are following an interest and inner drive.
The desire to climb is not necessarily the problem. In fact, it may be an important expression of healthy physical development.
The problem is that the child has chosen an unsuitable environment in which to fulfil that desire.
This is where thoughtful redirection becomes so valuable.
Rather than simply prohibiting the activity, we can recognise the developmental impulse beneath it and provide an appropriate opportunity for that impulse to be expressed.
The message becomes:
'You cannot climb on the table, but here is something you can climb.'
This is not permissiveness. It is not the absence of boundaries. It is an approach that combines clear limits with an understanding of the child's developmental needs.
The adult remains responsible for safety, establishing boundaries and ensuring that the environment is appropriate. However, instead of relying exclusively on verbal instructions, the adult actively shapes the environment to make successful exploration possible.
This reflects an important principle within Emmi Pikler's approach: the environment should offer children opportunities for meaningful, self-initiated movement, rather than requiring adults to continually direct, interrupt or correct their physical activity.
A thoughtfully produced piece of play equipment was devised exactly for this purpose - the Pikler triangle.
From interruption to participation
There is something quite significant about the difference between repeatedly interrupting a child's movement and providing an opportunity for that movement to continue.
When we continually say 'no', we risk creating an interaction in which the adult becomes preoccupied with stopping behaviour and the child becomes preoccupied with returning to it.
Redirection offers another possibility.
It allows the adult to remain connected to the child's intention while guiding them towards a safer and more appropriate experience.
This does not mean that every behaviour needs an alternative activity, or that children should never experience frustration when a boundary is established. Some things are simply not safe or permitted, and adults must intervene when necessary.
However, where a behaviour reflects a legitimate developmental need, it is worth considering whether we can provide an alternative rather than simply asking the child to suppress the impulse.
A child who wants to climb needs opportunities to climb. A child who wants to carry needs opportunities to carry. A child who wants to push, pull, reach, throw, drop, crawl or explore needs an environment in which these actions can be experienced safely.
The more opportunities children have to practise their emerging physical abilities, the more opportunities they have to develop coordination, body awareness, confidence and an understanding of their own capabilities.
The rungs of a Pikler triangle are spaced out at a certain regulated distance and the overall height of the equipment to a specified measurement. What happens is an infant can develop their emerging physical abilities one rung at a time and you often find the very young getting a great deal of satisfaction from simply hanging out on the bottom rung. As they master each step their capabilities and confidence grows.
Supporting the development of self-regulation
Perhaps the most important message is that self-regulation is not something we can demand of a young child before they are developmentally ready.
It is something that develops over time, supported by relationships, experience and the gradual acquisition of new capacities.
Our role is not simply to tell children what they cannot do. It is to help create the conditions in which they can discover what they can do.
Clear boundaries provide security. A thoughtfully prepared environment provides opportunity. A responsive adult helps children navigate the relationship between the two.
The Pikler triangle is therefore much more than a piece of climbing equipment. Used thoughtfully, it can become a practical expression of a much wider philosophy: that rather than continually interrupting children's natural developmental impulses, we can seek to understand them and provide meaningful opportunities for their expression.
Sometimes the most helpful response to a child's repeated attempt to do something they cannot do is not another 'no'.
It is an invitation to do something they can.